
|
An unapologetically opinionated view of what's brewing across the continent and around the globe. |
|||||||
|
Stephen Beaumont's
|
||||||
|
Kitchen Table Tasting -- Six Vintages of Niagara Falls EisbockFor quite some time now, I've harboured a fascination for cellaring beer. Thomas Hardy's, Chimay Grand Reserve, McChouffe, Maudite; you name it, they are all currently aging in my cellar as I patiently await the outcome -- good or bad! -- of their loosely controlled deterioration. In the early days of the craft beer renaissance in Ontario, however, beers that could be effectively cellared were few and far between, except for one: the Niagara Falls Brewing Company's Eisbock.At 8% alcohol by volume and thoroughly filtered, Eisbock is not what you might call a superlative candidate for the cellar -- a couple of extra points of alcohol and/or some bottle conditioning would be preferred. But over the years, it has proven itself to be worthy of aging and so I continue to put bottles down and conduct annual vertical tastings. This year, as you by now have surely surmised, was no exception. Present for this tasting were myself and my lovely wife, Christine, beer aficionado Alastair Fairweather, the brewer and part-owner of Toronto's Denison's Brewing Company brewpub and restaurant, Michael Hancock, and Michael's able assistant and award-winning homebrewer, Lorne Romano. The vintages sampled were, in order of tasting: 1996 (the current vintage); 1995; 1994; Eisbock Gold (the 1994 vintage aged an extra year in the tank at the brewery and further concentrated to 8.6% alcohol by volume); 1993; and 1991. The unusually dry 1992 vintage was absent because it had shown steep decline as early as 1994 and had therefore long since been removed from the cellar to be consumed while still enjoyable. For those unfamiliar with eisbock -- the style, not the brand -- it is made by first brewing and fermenting a normal bock beer and then concentrating said beer by partially freezing it and extracting the resultant ice. In a traditional eisbock, the finishing alcohol content lies somewhere on either side of the 10% alcohol by volume mark, and so even at 8% ABV, the Niagara Falls Eisbock can be considered on the weak side for the style. Niagara Falls claims to have been the first modern brewery outside of Germany to brew an eisbock when they launched theirs as the brewery's second brand in 1989. The Kitchen Table opinions of the 1996 Eisbock confirmed my thoughts from when I first tasted it in December of last year; namely that it tasted sweet, young and more than slightly immature. All of the tasters thought it alcoholic -- not a soft, warming type of alcohol, but a bold, intrusive style -- and most found it rather one-dimensional. Where there are these characteristics, however, I think there is also room for development and I will not be at all surprised if this vintage scores much better in subsequent years. The 1995 vintage was day to the 1996's night, with a wonderfully full body and a smoothly drinkable and rather complex character. Time has been very good to this beer and tasting it was almost enough to compel me to pull some of my cellared bottles up for more immediate enjoyment. But the older vintages still beckoned, so the cellar door stayed closed and I will be content to wait until next year. Both the 1994 vintage and the Eisbock Gold proved disappointing. The former had turned a bit musty and earthy and the latter had suffered badly from its cork finish, giving up a strong initial cork aroma, most of which we were eventually able to "burn off" through breathing, and a lingering cork taste. (The Gold was packaged in Champagne-style bottles and sealed with a cork, and I have accordingly stored my bottles on their sides.) It will be interesting to see next year if the corked nature of the Gold was an isolated case or if it carries through to the rest of my similarly-stored samples. 1993 was a near-consensus choice as the finest vintage of the tasting. In its complex aroma I picked up notes of rum-soaked raisins, toffee, cinnamon, very light roast and a hint of florals. Similarly, the sweetish body also demonstrated a pleasing complexity, and both Alastair and Michael even compared its creamy character to that of crème brullée. Overall, this was a thoroughly enjoyable vintage and one that I think still has a few more good years in it. After the creamy complexity of the 1993, tasting the dry subtlety of the 1991 was a tough transition to make. This vintage has definitely changed through the years and now offers flavours quite removed from those of its youth. The tanned leather notes I often find in older beers were there, along with a smoky woodiness that was picked up by nearly all of the tasters. Different, yes, but highly pleasurable proof that this beer does age with grace and dignity.
A Taste For Beer
|
Selected Events for March
Molson Pilot Brewery's Scotch AleIf the limited available quantities of February's Taste of the Month (Cantillon Gueuze Vigneronne) frustrated a number of you, this one is going to drive you completely mad! That's because no one can get their hands on this beer; not you, not me, not anyone!This elusive brew was poured for me by a former employee of Molson who had been holding on to it for about a year. I and a visiting brewer tasted it blind and were both blown away by it's bold, spicy and decidedly Belgian character. Then our jaws dropped to floor level when we found out that this thoroughly enjoyable brew came from Molson! It has been a tradition for some time for the Molson test brewery in Toronto to brew oddball and offbeat beers around Christmas. These beers, which have ranged from doppelbocks to lager-and-limes, have then been given away to employees as seasonal gifts. Having tasted a couple of years' worth of these test brews, I can safely say that they have never been terribly exciting beers...until now. Although it was certainly Belgian in tone, this brew had been labelled a Scotch Ale. Neither of us at the table that night could quibble too much over that malapropism, however, as we were too busy savouring the full, sweetish and lightly peppery flavours in our glasses. Proof, I had to observe, that truly exciting beers really can come from large-scale commercial breweries, or at least from their test brewery divisions.
Editorial -- Time for Crazy Horse Malt Liquor to Just Go AwayI don't usually include editorials in the World of Beer, primarily because I see the whole "unapologetically opinionated" thing a sort of extended editorial, but from time to time there arises an issue in the brewing industry that I believe is deserving of specific attention. To this end, I am pleased to present the first in an occasional series of editorial opinion features.In a Washington Post article dated February 18, Michael A. Fletcher writes of the continuing controversy over how Native Americans see themselves portrayed in popular North American culture. In particular, Fletcher focuses upon a brand of malt liquor brewed by G. Heileman (now owned by Stroh) under contract for the New York-based Hornell Brewing Company. The beer is called Crazy Horse Malt Liquor. Leaving aside the greater issue of the positioning of malt liquor as an inexpensive inebriant, and the much greater issue of how sports teams and other consumer products employ often derogatory native imagery and occasionally racist terminology to sell their wares, let me turn your attention to the concept of using the name of a native spiritual leader to sell beer. Can you imagine a Mother Teresa Dry? How about a Martin Luther King Jr. Ice Beer or perhaps a Prophet Mohammed Light? Each of those names would be viewed by the groups they affect with horror and outrage, and if any brewing company were to actually be ignorant enough to launch the brands in the first place, you can bet whatever you have that they wouldn't last long in the marketplace. Yet because Native Americans are a relatively marginalized group, we as a consumer society have told Hornell that it is alright for them to co-opt the name of one of native culture's most revered spiritual leaders and slap it on the side of 40-ounce bottle of high octane lager. Well, it's not alright, and it's high time that we let Hornell, G. Heileman and Stroh know that. The Crazy Horse Defense Project, a St. Paul, Minnesota-based national organization that is waging a campaign to remove the malt liquor from the market, has proposed a national boycott of another, more popular Hornell product called AriZona Ice Tea. I would like to go a step further and ask beer lovers everywhere to encourage the management of your favourite beer stores to remove Crazy Horse Malt Liquor from their shelves. Further, please tell the managers why you would like them to do this and encourage them to pass this information on to their distributor. Please note that this is not an issue of freedom of speech -- I do not challenge for one second the right that Hornell has to call their products whatever they wish -- but rather, it is a matter of courtesy, decency and respect. It may be too late to undo the past four years of insult that the brand has foisted upon native Americans through its abuse of one of their most revered leaders, but there is still time to prevent further damage.
|
||||||
|
If you have a product -- beer, book, CD-ROM or whatever -- that you would like to see
reviewed in this space, please send a message to worldofbeer@worldofbeer.com and we'll
send you back instructions on how to get it to us.
| |||||||
|
World of Beer Business Briefs
|
|||||||
|
Feedback response has been so great this past month that I'm introducing a new letter-and-response format for this section. I hope that this will allow me to answer the maximum number of letters and get to as many questions as possible. Let me know what you think about the new look of Feedback and, by all means, keep those e-mails coming.
If you have any comments, questions, hints or tips for Stephen Beaumont's World of Beer, we'd love to hear from you. Although we unfortunately can't promise individual replies to everyone who writes, we will present your comments and answer some of your questions in this space each month. Click Here: worldofbeer@worldofbeer.com.
|
|
||||||